Steven Engel, a prominent American attorney known for his extensive academic and professional background, has recently been appointed as an examiner in a high-profile bankruptcy investigation, sparking concerns within the US corporate bankruptcy sector over potential political influence in the selection process.

Engel’s appointment came from a division of the US Department of Justice (DoJ) to lead an inquiry into the circumstances surrounding the Chapter 11 filing by Hughes Satellite Systems in August. Examiner appointments are routine in Chapter 11 cases; they are intended to provide an independent review of matters relevant to the bankruptcy. Typically, the US Trustee’s Office, a DoJ arm responsible for overseeing bankruptcy matters, nominates examiners after soliciting input from involved parties and conducting its own evaluations. Historically, this process has been largely apolitical and technocratic, with minimal direct intervention from senior DoJ officials in Washington.

However, several leading bankruptcy lawyers have expressed unease about a perceived shift in the selection process under the current administration. They allege that senior levels within the DoJ have become more directly involved in picking examiners, overriding the traditional authority of the US Trustee’s Office. This change has intensified following the 2025 dismissal of Tara Twomey, the US Trustee program director appointed in 2023, who is now pursuing legal action to regain her position under civil service protections.

Sources close to Hughes creditor groups reported satisfaction with Engel’s credentials and expertise, although some insiders familiar with the examiner selection process suggested the DoJ’s central office had clearly pushed for Engel’s appointment. Similar concerns arose with the selection of Martin DeLuca as examiner in the bankruptcy of First Brands, an automotive parts company embroiled in allegations of multi-billion-dollar fraud. DeLuca, who leads the international private client practice at Boies Schiller Flexner, has known ties to former President Donald Trump and conservative legal circles, including pro bono work for Americans detained abroad during the Trump administration and legal representation of right-wing entities like Rumble and the Trump Media & Technology Group.

Despite DeLuca’s limited direct experience in high-profile bankruptcy prosecutions, his appointment has drawn criticism from some bankruptcy professionals, who view it as further evidence of political considerations influencing examiner nominations. One veteran attorney involved in recent examiner appointments described the new process as a departure from historic norms, emphasizing that examiner selection previously operated free from political factors. Another senior law firm executive disclosed efforts to identify Trump-related legal connections within their organization, aiming to secure lucrative roles supporting future examiners.

Those consulted did not suggest that the Department of Justice is influencing the content or conclusions of examiner reports. Instead, the primary concern hinges on whether examiner appointments have become a mechanism for rewarding political allies with financially advantageous assignments that can generate millions in legal fees.

The DoJ refuted these allegations in a statement, emphasizing that bankruptcy courts retain ultimate authority to approve examiners nominated by the US Trustee. The department asserted it remains committed to insulating examiner selection from politics and upholding transparency.

Boies Schiller Flexner also defended DeLuca’s selection, highlighting the firm’s competitive vetting process involving consultation with private stakeholders and court approval. The firm cited its depth of former prosecutors and bankruptcy lawyers as key strengths in managing complex proceedings.

Nonetheless, the appointments of Engel and DeLuca have heightened scrutiny of the examiner selection process, signaling increased attention on the potential intersection of politics and bankruptcy oversight moving forward.