Two distinct productions of Giacomo Puccini’s opera “Tosca” were presented in New York City last weekend, offering audiences contrasting interpretations of the well-known work within a 24-hour span. One performance took place at Carnegie Hall on Friday evening, featuring the New York Philharmonic under the direction of Gustavo Dudamel, while the other was a staged revival by the Metropolitan Opera on Saturday afternoon.
The Philharmonic’s concert rendition inaugurated a five-year initiative led by Dudamel, the orchestra’s newly appointed music and artistic director, to present operas in concert form at Carnegie Hall. While the choice of “Tosca” was seen as conventional rather than innovative, the orchestra’s performance provided an illuminating examination of Puccini’s score. Removing the music from the traditional pit setting onto the hall’s stage revealed intricate details in the orchestration. Dudamel’s interpretation highlighted thematic elements such as the villainous chord progressions associated with the antagonist Scarpia, which assumed a haunting, almost suffocating presence in the opera’s second act.
Key musical moments included a pastoral and atmospheric opening to the third act, enriched by a cello solo performed by principal cellist Matthew Christakos, who continues to impress since stepping into the role following Carter Brey’s retirement. Dudamel’s conducting was noted for effective balance and support of the vocalists, swiftly addressing misalignments between orchestra and singers.
Casting for the Philharmonic’s concert included tenor Jonas Kaufmann as Cavaradossi, whose performance was more vocally secure than a recent one with the Berlin Philharmonic, though signs of vocal strain remained. Soprano Marina Rebeka debuted in the role of Tosca, bringing a distinctive brightness and metallic timbre to the character. Baritone Ludovic Tézier’s portrayal of Scarpia combined lyrical allure with ferocity, delivering the text with exceptional clarity for non-Italian listeners. Despite these strengths, the Philharmonic’s interpretation was characterized by measured tempos that introduced moments of intensity but lacked the driving momentum typical of “Tosca’s” breathless dramatic pacing.
In contrast, the Metropolitan Opera’s staged production under the baton of Oksana Lyniv delivered a more visceral and forceful rendition. Lyniv’s conducting emphasized the powerful opening theme associated with Scarpia, embodying the menace and dominance described in the score.
The Met featured Saioa Hernández in her company debut as Tosca, offering a vocal and dramatic range from elegance to fierce intensity. Hernández commanded the stage during pivotal moments such as “Vissi d’arte” and the confrontation with Scarpia, portrayed by baritone Quinn Kelsey. Kelsey’s interpretation was noted for its commanding presence and vocal resonance, melding ruthlessness with vulnerability in response to Tosca’s character. Tenor SeokJong Baek’s portrayal of Cavaradossi was marked by ardent energy, particularly in his triumphant cry “Vittoria!” in the second act.
Overall, both productions highlighted the elasticity and enduring appeal of Puccini’s score. While the Philharmonic’s concert approach allowed for detailed musical exploration, the Met’s full staging delivered the opera’s intense emotional and dramatic narrative. Audiences were offered distinct but complementary experiences of a work that has remained a staple of operatic repertoire since its introduction to the United States in 1901.
