Last week, a group of academics, political figures, and diplomats from Italy and the United States convened in Rome for a two-day forum focused on democracy, education, civic virtue, and concerns about the potential decline of Western civilization. The event, held in a historic palazzo, was organized by the National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH), a U.S. federal agency that has recently aligned more closely with White House priorities emphasizing the defense of Western cultural and intellectual traditions.

Brian Burch, the U.S. ambassador to the Holy See and a former conservative political activist, opened discussions by addressing worries raised since the recent midterm elections, humorously comparing fears of democratic collapse to the “days of the fall of Rome.” He cautioned, however, that the West faces risks not only from external threats but from gradual internal compromises. “Decline is rarely imposed from the outside,” Burch said, “it is chosen, one comfortable compromise at a time.”

Titled “Classical Foundations and Moral Authority,” the conference gathered leading voices critical of modern secular liberal democracy and contemporary university curricula. Among the American participants were Patrick Deneen, a political theorist at the University of Notre Dame and author of *Why Liberalism Failed*; R.R. Reno, editor of the religious conservative journal *First Things*; and James Hankins, a former Harvard professor now affiliated with the University of Florida’s Hamilton School for Classical and Civic Education. The forum also featured John O’Sullivan, president of the Danube Institute, a Budapest-based think tank with ties to former Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban.

Panels covered a broad range of issues including education, artificial intelligence, law, and international affairs, frequently returning to concerns about Western democracies drifting from their moral and cultural foundations. Michael McDonald, chair of the NEH, emphasized in his opening remarks that the Western intellectual tradition underpins democratic governance, artistic achievement, and shared cultural heritage—yet acknowledged the possibility that this legacy could be eroding.

Speakers debated the definition and purpose of the Western tradition, questioning whether it should be taught as an ongoing dialogue with diverse perspectives or as a transmission of core truths. Deneen praised recent expansions in university civic thought centers and classical K-12 education but argued these efforts remain “insufficiently ambitious,” often reduced to promoting “viewpoint diversity” rather than a robust set of guiding principles. Conversely, Hankins stressed the importance of “intellectual honesty” in education, including critical engagement with ideas that challenge one’s own beliefs.

Religious themes were prominent throughout the conference. Marcello Pera, a philosopher and former Italian Senate president, highlighted the tension between liberal democracy’s emphasis on individual freedom and the historical Christian foundations of Western society. Burch echoed this view, citing conservative Bishop Robert Barron’s assertion that meaningful discussions about freedom and rights require acknowledgment of God. Reno commended Texas legislation mandating Bible instruction, describing the text as “the fountain of our humanistic culture.”

O’Sullivan linked failures in cultural and civic education to social unrest, pointing to recent riots in Paris as symptomatic of deeper societal breakdowns he attributed to educational deficiencies.

While no concrete policy directives emerged from the discussions, McDonald announced plans for a follow-up conference next year in Athens, underscoring the urgency of addressing the perceived challenges to Western cultural renewal. “Let’s try to be more urgent in Athens,” he said at the forum’s conclusion.