Three of the largest school districts in the United States—New York City, Los Angeles, and Chicago—are exploring alternatives to Google Search after the company declined to offer a version of its search tool without integrated artificial intelligence features. The decision follows Google’s announcement that, beginning next year, its education products will no longer have AI capabilities enabled by default. Instead, school administrators will have the option to activate AI tools, but there will be no search version available without AI chatbot functions.

This change has prompted concern among education officials, lawmakers, and parents, some of whom accuse Google of imposing AI technology on public schools without sufficient choice. The AI integration, critics argue, forces schools into a “use-it-or-lose-it” scenario where opting out of AI means losing access to an essential digital learning resource.

Kamar H. Samuels, chancellor of New York City schools, responded by indicating the district’s willingness to consider other search providers if Google does not revise its policy. “We refuse to accept the false binary Google has laid out,” Samuels said, emphasizing the district’s commitment to providing options beyond Google’s AI-enabled environment.

The issue highlights the growing dependence of school systems on Google’s interconnected suite of products, including Chromebook laptops and applications like Gmail and Docs, which have become foundational to classroom operations. As Google deepens the integration of AI into these platforms, questions arise about the balance between technological innovation and user choice in educational settings.

Some districts have already blocked Google’s AI features in search or are actively evaluating other solutions to preserve flexibility for students and educators. The forthcoming transition marks a critical point in how AI will shape the classroom experience and the role technology companies play in public education infrastructure.