Pierre Poilievre faces mounting challenges as leader of Canada’s Conservative Party following a series of setbacks that have weakened his position within the party and diminished public support. Poilievre lost his parliamentary seat in the most recent federal election, a blow that contributed to the Liberals securing a majority government. Since then, several members of his caucus have departed, further eroding Conservative unity.
Recent polling reflects a significant decline in Poilievre’s standing among voters, with his preferred prime minister rating at just 20 percent, well behind Liberal figure Mark Carney, who commands 56 percent in the same poll. Poilievre has also experienced significant turnover among his staff, fueling speculation about his leadership’s viability.
The Conservative Party faces a critical moment ahead of by-elections scheduled for December 7, which could result in the loss of a long-held Conservative seat in Brantford. Party insiders suggest that a leadership challenge could emerge soon, especially if Poilievre’s position continues to weaken.
Potential successors are being discussed within party ranks, with several prominent figures considered capable of revitalizing Conservative prospects. James Moore, a former cabinet minister from British Columbia known for his bilingualism and extensive political experience, has been mentioned as a candidate who could combine substantive policy knowledge with a less polarizing approach than Poilievre. Moore recently appeared publicly alongside former Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Peter MacKay, signaling possible alignment within the party establishment.
Another figure attracting attention is Mark Mulroney, a banking executive with a background at Goldman Sachs and currently Global Vice-Chair of CIBC. Although he has never held elected office, Mulroney’s financial expertise and his family’s political legacy—his father, Brian Mulroney, served as prime minister—make him a potentially strong outsider candidate. The comparison to Mark Carney, who also transitioned from finance to politics without prior electoral experience, has been noted, though Mulroney’s sister Caroline, a former Ontario cabinet minister, has not indicated interest in federal politics.
The deputy party leader, Melissa Lantsman, is viewed as a possible option to take on leadership responsibilities. Lantsman, a Toronto MP known for her sharp communication skills and multilingualism, could broaden the party’s appeal beyond its traditional base. However, her close association with Poilievre may present obstacles to her advancement.
Jason Kenney, former premier of Alberta and key figure in Conservative politics, remains a notable contender. With extensive cabinet experience and expertise in immigration, energy, and relations with the United States, Kenney’s leadership credentials are well established. Nevertheless, his tenure as head of Alberta’s United Conservative Party ended amid internal dissent, which could hinder his prospects at the national level.
On Canada’s East Coast, Nova Scotia Premier Tim Houston also represents a potential leadership candidate, known for his pragmatic political style and recent electoral success.
Several other Conservative figures, such as MPs Adam Chambers and Michelle Rempel Garner, along with Ontario Premier Doug Ford, face challenges related to limited French-language skills, an important consideration in national leadership contests.
Despite challenges, Poilievre retains significant support among the party’s hard-right faction, a group that has dominated Conservative politics since the early 1990s. However, the party’s historical performance has been uneven, holding power only nine of the past 33 years. Analysts suggest that to broaden its electoral appeal, the party may need a leader willing to move closer to the political center.
The timeline for a leadership change remains uncertain. Some party members believe the opportunity to replace Poilievre is optimal while his support is at a low point, but others anticipate his continued leadership into the next election cycle. Meanwhile, Carney’s current popularity is expected to decline over time, potentially allowing the Conservatives to regain momentum.
Within the party, there is no indication that a dramatic leadership shift akin to the resignation of the Liberal deputy leader Chrystia Freeland will occur to reshape Conservative fortunes. Consequently, the future leadership of the party remains a focal question as it seeks to recover ground ahead of the 2029 federal election.
