Nicole Kidman and Sandra Bullock have returned as the Owens sisters in the sequel to the 1998 cult film "Practical Magic," which premiered recently in theaters. Directed by Susanne Bier and based on Alice Hoffman’s novel "The Book of Magic," the film continues the story of a family of witches grappling with a generational curse that causes any man an Owens woman loves to meet an untimely death.
Set years after the original, the sequel centers on Sally Owens (Bullock), who has been widowed twice, and her sister Gillian (Kidman). Sally, still mourning, insists that their daughters—Kylie (Joey King) and Antonia (Maisie Williams)—remain unaware of their magical heritage. The narrative follows the extended Owens family gathering for the birthday of their elder aunt Bridget, known as Jet (Dianne Wiest), who senses her time is running out and aims to finally break the family curse. The plot weaves through events including an accident involving Kylie’s boyfriend and a journey to England, where they meet Ian Wright (Lee Pace), a handsome academic historian of magic.
Critics note that while the sequel embraces themes of family legacy and empowerment, its tone and execution have drawn mixed reactions. The continuation focuses on middle-aged women, a somewhat rare narrative angle in fantasy films, highlighting Sally and Gillian’s relationship and their evolving roles as matriarchs in the magical lineage. Bullock and Kidman’s performances, particularly their comedic timing and chemistry, receive praise for bringing warmth and authenticity to their characters.
However, some find the story’s twists and tonal shifts less effective than the original’s distinctive blend of whimsy and gothic aesthetic. The sequel is noted to feel at times uneven, with an inconsistent narrative that alternates between heartfelt family moments and lighter, sometimes awkward romantic elements. The film incorporates familiar motifs such as cozy New England settings and quaint English countryside scenes but reportedly lacks the lush, atmospheric styling that contributed to the first film's appeal.
The younger generation’s roles have been met with a divided response. Joey King’s portrayal of the more active and bold daughter is appreciated, whereas Maisie Williams’s character is seen as underused. Some critics also find the inclusion of contemporary cultural elements, like Olivia Rodrigo’s music, a token gesture that does little to deepen the story.
The film attempts to update its themes, briefly touching on gender dynamics with a character asserting that men can now do anything women can—a moment suggesting potential for a stronger feminist message—but this thread remains undeveloped.
Overall, the sequel appears to serve primarily as comfort viewing for fans of the original, invoking nostalgia while expanding the Owens family saga. It retains moments of charm and humor, anchored by its three generations of actresses, though it elicits debate over whether it fully recaptures the original’s unique magic.