ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — Defensive struggles marred the New York Yankees’ 5-2 loss to the Tampa Bay Rays in Game 2 of their playoff series on Monday night. Yankees manager Aaron Boone chose to keep the same lineup used in Game 1, including Ryan McMahon at third base despite the infielder’s recent difficulties, aiming to emphasize defense. However, a series of errors, starting with McMahon’s misplay on Tampa Bay’s second pitch, contributed significantly to the defeat.

McMahon’s error occurred early in the first inning when a ground ball by Rays leadoff hitter Yandy Díaz bounced unpredictably on Tropicana Field’s turf, leading to a miscued backhand attempt that allowed the ball to slip past him. This miscue set off a chain reaction that resulted in the first unearned run of the game, compounded by a throwing error from Jazz Chisholm Jr. and a catcher’s interference call on Austin Wells.

Boone acknowledged he had considered other options at third base, including starting Anthony Volpe, but opted against it due to Volpe’s limited experience at the position and concerns over the playing surface. José Caballero was also an option, with Boone describing him as “very much in play” throughout the playoffs. Caballero played as a defensive replacement during the game and expressed readiness to contribute when called upon.

At the plate, McMahon struggled to provide offensive support. He finished the night 0-for-3 with a walk and was eventually replaced by pinch hitter Paul Goldschmidt in the eighth inning. Over four postseason games, McMahon has recorded only one hit in seven at-bats, along with two walks. His historical record against Tampa Bay starter Freddy Peralta, who pitched Game 2, is similarly underwhelming.

The Rays announced that Nick Martinez, a right-handed pitcher, will start Game 3. This decision may present Boone with further lineup adjustments, as McMahon is a left-handed batter who typically fares better against right-handed pitching.

Reflecting on the loss, McMahon cited frustration and some anger within the team but maintained a belief that the series remains contested. The Yankees will need to address their defensive lapses and adapt their approach as the series continues.